Christian schools’ legal challenge against VAT on school fees

An independent faith school has launched a legal challenge against the government’s plans to introduce VAT on private school fees.

The King’s School in Fair Oak, Hampshire, said the plans, due to come into effect in January, would be unlawful discrimination as it could force Christian schools to close.

Two hundred and seventy faith schools are asking for a VAT exemption for those which charge less than the government pays for a child to be educated at a state school.

The government said the revenue would be spent on state education, including funding 6,500 new teachers in England.

The King’s School, which has 230 pupils aged four to 16, charges about £7,900 per year, per child, which is £10,000 pounds less than the average independent school in England.

Each pupil educated at a state school costs the government £7,690 per year.

“I think the government has either misunderstood or ignored the diversity in independent schools,” said Caroline Santer, head teacher at King’s School.

“It’s not just about Eton and Harrow, and boaters.”

Three quarters of the school budget goes towards salaries, with teachers earning about 70% of what they would in the state sector.

“Working here is a mission calling because of its unique Christian ethos,” Mrs Santer said.

The King’s School is one of three faith schools working with lawyers at the Christian Legal Centre to launch a judicial review if VAT is brought in from January.

“I’d like to see the government make fees more proportionate, acknowledging that parents should have the ability to choose how they want their children educated in accordance with their religious beliefs,” Mrs Santer continued.

The Department for Education said the money raised would to go towards public finances and help improve education and outcomes for young people.

Ministers said they did not expect raising VAT would cause private school fees to go up by 20%, as they did not have to reflect the increase in what they charged.

But Mrs Santer said the margins at The King’s School were too tight for them to absorb any extra cost.

“We are going to have to pass it on to parents and it’s going to be devastating,” she said.

“A few families have already said they can’t make the money work and have withdrawn their children.”